Difference between revisions of "Celebrity achievement"

From Geohashing
 
m (Rejecting achievement)
 
(One intermediate revision by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Proposal talk|date=2009-09-29}}
+
{{Rejected|reason = there were issues with definitions, and it would work better as a gratuitous ribbon}}
  
 
{{gratuitous ribbon  
 
{{gratuitous ribbon  
Line 16: Line 16:
 
* The amount of contact needs to be defined as well. Is it enough if you spot them through a crowd? Say hi? Shake hands? I'd assume "going to a concert before going to the hashpoint" shouldn't count.
 
* The amount of contact needs to be defined as well. Is it enough if you spot them through a crowd? Say hi? Shake hands? I'd assume "going to a concert before going to the hashpoint" shouldn't count.
  
{{ProposedAchievementsNav}}
+
{{rejected achievements}}

Latest revision as of 23:02, 3 June 2024

This achievement was proposed in the past, but has been rejected, because there were issues with definitions, and it would work better as a gratuitous ribbon. Please read the discussion page for more details.

As per the page proposed achievements: If an achievement has strong opposition and the reasons for opposition are not resolved through discussion, then the proposed achievements category is replaced with the rejected achievements category, the reason explained succinctly on the page, and the page otherwise marked to make sure it isn't confused with an achievements page.


GoldStar.JPG
Yerushalmi and his wife earned the Celebrity Geohash achievement
by meeting a guy in a monkey suit on the way to the (31, 34) geohash on 2009-08-16.
2009-08-16 31 34 Kofiko2.jpg
  • The geohasher must have met a celebrity on the way to or from the hashpoint
  • The celebrity in question must meet a certain minimum definition of fame (I'm open to suggestions of how to define it. Perhaps a page on Wikipedia about them? That might be too broad. Though it would neatly cover the "who gives a damn about movie stars, I want to meet Cory Doctorow" attitude most of us share.)
  • The amount of contact needs to be defined as well. Is it enough if you spot them through a crowd? Say hi? Shake hands? I'd assume "going to a concert before going to the hashpoint" shouldn't count.
Rejected achievements
Airborne · Awesome addiction · Bingo · Boats are for sissies! · Celebrity · Children of the Hash · Christmas GPS · Citation Needed · Day Late and a Dollar Short · Dogwalking · Drunk · False start · Ferry · Fibonacci · Fire safety · First aid · Foreign · Free Culture · Good Samaritan · Hashholiday · Irony · Lying Down Game · Mapillary · Motorcycle · Mythical beast · Over and under · Polyhash · Red spider · Reflowered Graticule · Relay · Rite of passage · Romantic · Rubik's Cube · Samaritan · Save the Crop · Serendipity · Sharing · Ski · Smoking · Stacking · Strange attractor · Travelling hashman · Tree dresser · Valentine's · Virgin World · With the dead · You Lost