Difference between revisions of "Talk:Roanoke, Virginia"
imported>Phyzome m (Talk:Blue Ridge, Virginia moved to Talk:Roanoke, Virginia: Biggest city in the grat.) |
m |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
== Page name == | == Page name == | ||
| − | I've visited Roanoke and Lynchburg, and I'm pretty sure Roanoke is larger. If it was up to me, I'd go with that. I doesn't matter if the town is near the center, IMHO it's more important that the name has recognition. Besides, [[Lynchburg, | + | Feel free to copy this comment to discussion in any case, but I propose this title simply because this graticule certainly isn't Roanoke, nor Lynchburg. (Roanoke-Salem would be a more convenient center point, and Lynchburg would be a convenient focus for what is currently known as "Appomattox," but there's the obvious problem of "the lines fall where they fall." Thus, I rejected Roanoke-Lynchburg as a name. Following the tradition of the "[[Shenandoah Valley, Virginia]]" graticule nearby, I thought something indicating a similar but unique name would be an acceptable compromise. I have never been particularly clear on the preferred definition of "the Blue Ridge Mountains," but as Blue Ridge does appear in the graticule, I found it appropriate. (Plus, this is a remarkably good graticule for me personally were I to explore my family's roots/visit nearby relatives!) --[[User:James.|James.]] 18:11, 29 May 2008 (UTC) |
| + | |||
| + | I've visited Roanoke and Lynchburg, and I'm pretty sure Roanoke is larger. If it was up to me, I'd go with that. I doesn't matter if the town is near the center, IMHO it's more important that the name has recognition. Besides, [[Lynchburg, Virginia]] can always redirect to [[Roanoke, Virginia]]. -- [[User:Jevanyn|Jevanyn]] 10 Jun 2008 | ||
Latest revision as of 22:09, 4 March 2020
Good job to whoever is doing this. I live on the border of this graticule, and would like to see someone that can cover this page.
Page name
Feel free to copy this comment to discussion in any case, but I propose this title simply because this graticule certainly isn't Roanoke, nor Lynchburg. (Roanoke-Salem would be a more convenient center point, and Lynchburg would be a convenient focus for what is currently known as "Appomattox," but there's the obvious problem of "the lines fall where they fall." Thus, I rejected Roanoke-Lynchburg as a name. Following the tradition of the "Shenandoah Valley, Virginia" graticule nearby, I thought something indicating a similar but unique name would be an acceptable compromise. I have never been particularly clear on the preferred definition of "the Blue Ridge Mountains," but as Blue Ridge does appear in the graticule, I found it appropriate. (Plus, this is a remarkably good graticule for me personally were I to explore my family's roots/visit nearby relatives!) --James. 18:11, 29 May 2008 (UTC)
I've visited Roanoke and Lynchburg, and I'm pretty sure Roanoke is larger. If it was up to me, I'd go with that. I doesn't matter if the town is near the center, IMHO it's more important that the name has recognition. Besides, Lynchburg, Virginia can always redirect to Roanoke, Virginia. -- Jevanyn 10 Jun 2008
