Talk:Geohash by proxy achievement

Did you really mean to say CREATING a GPS-carrying device, i.e. you must both build the vehicle and navigate it to the geohash? You intend to exclude people who buy RC vehicles? -Robyn 05:15, 20 October 2008 (UTC)

Definitely not - I figured that combining a GPS with a carrier of some sort is a creative act. I didn't go with the RC Geohash idea because I didn't want to exclude kites, and I wanted to make it as general as possible. Any suggestions as to phrasing will be appreciated. --Pardey 05:20, 20 October 2008 (UTC)

Do you really need to actually send a GPS device in with the RC unit? There are plenty of geohashers who don't actually use a GPS (as for many locations in certain parts of the world it's quite possible to be extremely accurate using map data). What if, for example, you sent in an RC car / plane with a camera and took a photo of the RC unit at or over the hashpoint? For a normal geohash this would be suitable if you went instead of the RC unit (ie without any GPS)...--CJ 12:04, 20 October 2008 (UTC)

I think this should count, too. If you navigate any device to the hashpoint and return it to you (throwing stones doesn't count!), it shouldn't matter if it's a GPS device or not, as long as it could as well have been one (this implies a certain minimum weight and size). Bonus points if you let it leave a hashmark. --Ilpadre 14:19, 29 October 2008 (UTC)

I see your point, but I wasn't thinking of this as something that could be done at every hashpoint. On the talk page where the original discussion took place (Talk:2008-10-14_49_12), I gave the example of a water hash flown over by an RC plane (i.e. the hash couldn't be reached without the vehicle/device). That said, how about different ranks akin to the Air Geohash? We could have Ground, Air, Water, and Rube Goldberg (for exceptional weirdness of device). Maybe an additional modifier for the vehicle reaching a point otherwise inaccessible to the geohasher (Air Scout).